Commentary

Home
Discover More
Commentary

December 11, 2017 by Editor in Commentary, Discover More

Fracking is Part of the Climate Change Problem, Not Its Solution — NYT Has It Wrong

The New York Times’ seemingly objective and forthright piece titled “Climate Change is Complex. We’ve Got Answers to Your Questions” is instantly undermined by its assertion that fracked gas from

November 20, 2017 by Editor in Commentary, Discover More

A New Solution to Trump’s Relentless Attacks on the Environment

The NY Times article, Why Has the E.P.A. Shifted on Toxic Chemicals? An Industry Insider Helps Call the Shots, exposes the efforts by Donald Trump’s EPA to undermine critical protections for

October 31, 2017 by admin9698 in Commentary, Discover More

How Our Constitution Can Save the Environment

In the NY times article “Corporations Have Rights. Why Shouldn’t Rivers?” we learn about a recently filed lawsuit in which a judge is being asked to recognize the Colorado River

Green Amendments For The Generations

2 days ago

" “ICE and DHS are seeking to strong-arm Pennsylvania and the communities of Hamburg and Tremont into accepting their efforts to transform windowless warehousing into immigration detention centers, regardless of the devastating harm, impact and costs to our communities and environment,” said Maya van Rossum, a member of the Delaware Riverkeeper and founder of Green Amendments For The Generations." ... See MoreSee Less

Environmental organizations look to intervene over proposed ICE detention centers in Berks, Schuylkill

www.mcall.com

Green Amendments For The Generations and the Delaware Riverkeeper Network on Friday filed petitions seeking to intervene in an appeal filed by the federal government.

View on Facebook

Green Amendments For The Generations

2 days ago

We so appreciate voices like Erica Beverett, Lead Organizer from Parents Engaging Parents uplifting the power of the #GreenAmendment in NJ and the values it will bring to protect already overburdened communities ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Green Amendments For The Generations

2 days ago

Press alert for Earth DayLeading Michigan State Legislators and advocates will gather to announce filing of the Michigan Green Amendment that would protect the right of all the people of the state to a clean and healthy environment, including clean water, air, and soils; balanced ecosystems; and a stable climate. If passed, Michigan would be the first state to explicitly recognize and protect the environmental justice values of a healthy environment, as well as the right to a safe and stable climate.Earth Day, April 22, 2026, 12:45 pmMichigan State Capitol100 N. Capitol Ave., Lansing, MI 48933Room 405, Senate Press Roomforthegenerations.org/events/michigan-green-amendment-press-conference/ ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Green Amendments For The Generations

4 days ago

There are over 4000 data centers and counting in the United States. There's a good chance that there may be a new project coming to town near you. What should you know? What questions should you ask? What do the laws say? How can we stop them? We answer these questions in our webinar April 21st. Please join us to learn more!Register here:Apr 21, 2026 06:00bit.ly/datacenters3 ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Green Amendments For The Generations

5 days ago

Press Release:Berks & Schuylkill Counties, PA; Harrisburg, PA: Today, April 17, 2026, two environmental organizations, Green Amendments For The Generations and the Delaware Riverkeeper Network, have filed legal petitions to help stop the Department of Homeland Security from advancing efforts to transform two Pennsylvania warehouses into Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detention facilities. The proposed facilities have faced state and local opposition due to their projected environmental and community impacts. The environmental organizations filed their petitions with the Pennsylvania Environmental Hearing Board seeking to intervene in the case titled Department of Homeland Security and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of Environmental Protection (EHB Docket No. 2026-030-L), which was filed by DHS on April 8.The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has purchased two warehouses, one in Berks County and one in Schuylkill County, that according to public documents will overtax community water supplies and overwhelm sewage treatment operations, as well as threaten other environmental and community harms. In response, the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (PADEP) issued Administrative Orders that would prevent DHS from advancing the ICE detention facilities as proposed. PADEP made clear that the facilities could not operate without making needed modifications and securing multiple state and local approvals to address concerns regarding drinking water, wastewater, environmental, health, safety, and fire suppression concerns. The DHS has appealed the Administrative Orders to the Pennsylvania Environmental Hearing Board, seeking to have the orders amended. If the environmental organizations’ petitions are granted, the organizations will become party to the case as Intervenors, with the opportunity to fully participate in defense of the state Administrative Orders and efforts to prevent DHS from advancing its plans as proposed, without necessary environmental protections, reviews, approvals and permits. “ICE and the Department of Homeland Security are seeking to strong-arm Pennsylvania and the communities of Hamburg and Tremont into accepting their efforts to transform windowless warehousing into immigration detention centers, regardless of the devastating harm, impact and costs to our communities and environment,” said Maya van Rossum, the Delaware Riverkeeper and Founder of the Green Amendments For The Generations organization. “If allowed to move forward, these ICE detention facilities threaten to undermine community drinking and groundwater systems, while at the same time overwhelming communities with mass quantities of sewage pollution that their existing facilities simply cannot handle. The result will be people potentially denied drinking water, streams overwhelmed with pollution, fire companies potentially unable to access the water they need to respond to a fire emergency, and irreversible harm to the water resources and natural environments important to local residents for their quality of life, enjoyment of their property, and recreational joys of life.”“At the same time, I worry about the very foreseeable threat of harm the incarcerated detainees will face; potentially being denied essential access to clean and healthy water for drinking and bathing; proper access to flushable toilets and sanitary conditions; and the water that would be required to tamp out a fire should one break out in these facilities. Given the known lack of water and sewage infrastructure needed to properly serve the high numbers being proposed for the Berks and Schuylkill County warehouses, it is very foreseeable that these facilities could result in dangerous and inhumane conditions for the detainees, while at the same time harming the surrounding communities,” adds van Rossum.According to the petitions, the organizations should be granted intervention in order to provide evidence and arguments regarding applicable laws, but also regarding the Pennsylvania Green Amendment that constitutionally protects the rights of all Pennsylvanians to pure water, clean air and a healthy environment, and creates a duty on government officials in the state to protect natural resources for both present and future generations.Background & DetailsICE purchased the warehouse facility in Schuylkill County, located at 50 Rausch Creek Rd, Tremont, PA, on January 15, 2026. According to the PADEP Administrative Order issued for the site, the warehouse was purchased for $119,515,000. ICE intends to hold up to 7,500 people at this location. In addition to those held at the facility, employees will be needed to run the operations. ICE purchased the warehouse facility in Berks County, located at 3501 Mountain Rd, Hamburg, PA, on January 26, 2026. According to the PADEP Administrative Order, the warehouse was purchased for $87,402,500. The facility would hold up to 1,500 detainees. In addition to detainees, there will be employees working at the facility, which will increase the numbers of individuals that need to be supported by the facility’s infrastructure.On March 5, 2026, the PADEP issued Administrative Orders to ICE regarding the federal agency’s intention to use the Schuylkill County and Berks County warehouse facilities as immigration detention facilities. The PADEP Administrative Orders clearly identified legal obligations, limitations and prohibitions regarding drinking water and sewage treatment as related to the proposed ICE detention facilities. The Administrative Orders prevent ICE from operating the two warehouse facilities as detention centers as proposed, unless and until they fulfill a series of clearly articulated legal requirements.The Administrative Orders also clearly identify the many ways that the plans to house such a high volume of detaineeswill overwhelm the drinking and wastewater systems needed to serve surrounding communities, and could result in a series of environmental and community harms. For example, according to the Administrative Orders:• Up to 900,000 gallons per day of water would be needed to support 7,500 detainees at the Tremont facility. This amount exceeds the 400,000 gallon per day capacity of the Schuylkill County Municipal Authority (SCMA) Tremont Public Water System and amounts to 90% of the system’s 1,000,000 gallon storage tank that is needed to support the town’s drinking water and fire protection needs.• The 450,000 to 1,000,000 gallons per day of sewage that would be produced by 7,500 detained individuals “will overwhelm SCMA’s existing collection system and pump station, and hydraulically overload the Tremont Wastewater Treatment Plant.” SCMA is only authorized to treat 500,000 gallons per day of wastewater at the Tremont Wastewater Treatment Plant.• “Sending 450,000 to 1,000,000 gallons per day of sewage from the [warehouse site] to the Tremont Wastewater Treatment Plant will result in the uncontrolled discharge of untreated or inadequately treated sewage to Swatara Creek from the Tremont Wastewater Treatment Plant”—in violation of both state and federal law.• In order to support 1,500 people detained at the Berks County facility, 180,000 gallons per day of water would be required. The current water system serving the Upper Bern facility can provide a maximum of 12,240 gallons per day and does not currently conform to approved construction plans.• In Upper Bern, the current applicable Sewage Approval Plan is based on a maximum 8,000 gallons of sewage per day from the warehouse facility; and the Township Wastewater Treatment Plant has a maximum hydraulic capacity of 206,000 gallons per day of sewage. If operated as proposed, to serve 1,500 detainees, the ICE facility would produce up to 225,000 gallons per day of sewage, far exceeding the current approved Plan and the maximum hydraulic capacity of the Town’s wastewater treatment plant.On March 17, 2026, ICE wrote PADEP urging it to relax, modify, circumvent, extend, suspend or otherwise alter or weaken the provided mandates in the Administrative Orders and in Pennsylvania State Law as they pertain to the Upper Bern Township and the Tremont Township detention facility proposals.On March 24, 206, PADEP responded to ICE, identifying the many reasons why the March 17 requests were inappropriate and otherwise not in compliance with law, and why PADEP would not be granting those requests.On April 8, 2026, DHS appealed the two administrative orders with the Pennsylvania Environmental Hearing Board (EHB). The DHS ICE appeal asserts, among other things, that the Administrative Orders “unreasonably interfere with and encroach upon a federal law enforcement agency’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities of enforcing the nation’s immigration laws.”If the Delaware Riverkeeper Network and Green Amendments For The Generations petitions are granted, the organizations will become party to the case as Intervenors, with the opportunity to fully participate in the legal proceedings. ###bit.ly/EnvirosChallengeICECenters ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook